knightly the Sneptaur

  • 0 Posts
  • 367 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2023

help-circle

  • Of course they should. And people who do Nazi expressions on TV should suffer the expected social consequences, because people should be responsible for the things they say and do.

    Are you gonna defend everyone who expresses a “history of fucking your mom” this way, too?

    Or are you going to admit that appealing to freedom of expression isn’t really an argument in defense of a persistent pattern of behavior that includes but did not culminate with a literal Nazi salute?











  • popularism

    Did you mean “populism” or is this a distinct term with a different definition?

    Everyone wants a “trump” - even the leftists, they just want a “trump” who aligns with their ideology.

    Actual leftist here, our ideology is that there should be no "trump"s. You seem to be talking about right-wing liberals like the Democrats, who explicitly reject populism in favor of legalism and bipartisanship.

    You want a “leftist trump” - somebody who will trash the same institutions to get your way.

    Again, if we got our way then no one person would be able to “trash institutions”. Please stop projecting, we know that every right-wing accusation is a confession.

    But - in a representative democracy there needs to be compromise and debate. The parties should work together to find paths forward.

    This reads like an admission that the USA is not a representative democracy, as has been well established academically: https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746

    These norms are important though.

    You can, and will, say that “nothing at all matters anymore because Trump doesn’t care” and I hear you.

    Please, do expand upon this acknowledgement that we shouldn’t bother with “norms” when they are being so flagrantly ignored.

    But I caution about seeking your own “trump” because the framework of our government is more important than the policies its passing over the long run.

    For the third time, please stop accusing “the left” of sharing “the right”'s ideology re: authoritarian leadership. It’s extremely transparent.

    He was chosen by the people

    America has never had democratic elections. Our electoral system is designed so that “the people” don’t have any agency to resist the dominance of capital.

    that’s why I think democrats are voting for his nominees. They’re upholding the norms and traditions as they have.

    Is this an admission that the norms and traditions are bad, or an admission that the Democrats care more about bipartisanship than the threat that Trump’s administration poses?