I think this place is too fragmented into instances to ever generate a front page anywhere near what r/all is.

If I understand this page right, https://lemm.ee will never show the top post of the day from https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/, https://discuss.tchncs.de/, or https://feddit.uk/.

And the “front page/general” site is already split into several instances (https://vlemmy.net/, https://lemmy.world/, https://sh.itjust.works/, https://lemmy.fmhy.ml/ and https://lemmy.one/, all claiming to be “a general front page lemmy instance”)

So what’s the deal, which one are we betting on as the place to direct all the new traffic? What’s the contender for primary public internet bulletin board? Right now the arrow to an alternative is looking like this: https://i.imgur.com/L1XsBy6.pngd

I’m personally guessing the conclusion is already reached; We have no place we’re betting on. We’re disinterested in pushing for any particular result. We don’t expect people to migrate. Many might not even want them to.

  • TexMexBazooka@lemm.eeEnglish
    11·
    2 years ago

    So what’s the deal, which one are we betting on as the place to direct all the new traffic?

    We aren’t. That’s the thing, there isn’t a single place with lemmy. There’s lots of places that all communicate between each other.

    • Comment105@lemm.eeOPEnglish
      02·
      2 years ago

      As I expected. Lemmy does not want to compete.

      I also expect this place to be dead and forgotten by the end of the year, a few mentions and visits on occasion, but never growing past a maximum of ~100 participants in the most active posts.

      • TexMexBazooka@lemm.eeEnglish
        1·
        2 years ago

        Do you understand how Lemmy-and the fediverse in a broader sense-works exactly? It doesn’t need to compete head to head with reddit. See, back in ye olden days, reddit had a somewhat higher barrier to entry and catered to people who were more technically minded and moving away from increasingly commercialized social media platforms.

        Does this sound familiar?

        Lemmy has a long way to go, but coming in here and waving the white flag after less than a week is a little foolish.

        • Comment105@lemm.eeOPEnglish
          01·
          2 years ago

          Lemmy has a long way to go, but coming in here and waving the white flag after less than a week is a little foolish.

          Be honest with yourself. If lemmy was an attractive alternative, you would’ve seen much more rapid growth these last couple days. Lemmy simply wasn’t ready for prime-time when this opportunity arose, maybe it will be later.

          I’ll leave this here: https://old.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/149cna4/like_all_blowups_on_reddit_this_one_will_pass_as/jo4ebot/

          A fun thing to point out is that this little comment has more engagement than almost every post on Lemmy. All but 10.

          • WarmSoda@lemm.eeEnglish
            2·
            1 year ago

            If lemmy was an attractive alternative, you would’ve seen much more rapid growth these last couple days.

            This didn’t age well ;)

          • AyyLMAO@exploding-heads.comEnglish
            1·
            2 years ago

            Ayy LMAO wth are you talking about?

            Check stats from beehaw

            Sopuli

            Just some random examples, because the new BIG servers haven’t even started registering on the stats. Speaking of new servers, the number of servers have DOUBLED since last month to over 160 instances.

            The lemmyverse have grown like never before

            • Comment105@lemm.eeOPEnglish
              01·
              2 years ago

              Wow, it grew from dozens to hundreds!

              You should’ve seen way more. You weren’t good enough to retain anything near the potential, the majority of replies to people suggesting the fediverse as an alternative commented or upvoted sentiment indicating that that didn’t like what they saw. The rest, a minority, were mostly along the lines of “It’s strange, but not that bad.”

              It doesn’t help that you promote instances that look like something from a temp-mail domain. Way to advertise.

          • TexMexBazooka@lemm.eeEnglish
            0·
            2 years ago

            Be honest with yourself. If lemmy was an attractive alternative, you would’ve seen much more rapid growth these last couple days. Lemmy simply wasn’t ready for prime-time when this opportunity arose, maybe it will be later.

            Compared to the amount of traffic before people started migrating it’s doing exponentially better than it was prior lol. The fact of the matter is lemmy takes a little bit to fully understand, so there will be a barrier to entry that only early adopters will get over. Growth will be slow for sure, and lemmy might not take off. But the Fediverse as a whole seems to be the Internet’s response to a increasingly corporate run social media environment.

            A fun thing to point out is that this little comment has more engagement than almost every post on Lemmy. All but 10.

            You have no idea how Lemmy works

            • Comment105@lemm.eeOPEnglish
              01·
              2 years ago

              Go tell those spergs over there how Lemmy works, and see if that convinces them to change their mind.

              The results speak for themselves, this is a bad new user experience and will need thorough consideration and clever restructuring. I think you’re too satisfied with the fact that it’s functional at all.

              The Fediverse won’t be any kind of meaningful response to corporate social media until you stop being satisfied with just the front row audience.