• 0 Posts
  • 399 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
cake
Cake day: March 5th, 2024

help-circle











  • From the first article:

    The Kurds told reporters covering the offensive that there were a thousand Islamic State fighters at the mountain base.

    While another source disagrees, this is a “he said she said” situation.

    From the second:

    Ground-launched cluster strikes caused hundreds of civilian casualties across Iraq. Human Rights Watch documented cases in most of the major cities, including al-Hilla, al-Najaf, Karbala’, Baghdad, and Basra. Doctors at local hospitals provided statistics that supported individual testimony of deaths and injuries. The majority of these casualties resulted from the heavy use of cluster munitions in populated areas where soldiers and civilians commingled.

    The third quotes the very paragraph above from the second, but quotes around and omits the line about areas where soldiers and civilians comingled.

    From the fourth:

    Although human-rights activists insist that the coalition could have done more to protect civilians, Townsend is right: unlike Russia, America does not bomb indiscriminately. The U.S. razed an entire city, killing thousands in the process, without committing a single obvious war crime.

    Note, US propaganda aside, I absolutely agree that war crimes were committed, specifically with regards to the use of certain types of munitions. This is a separate allegation from deliberate targeting and indiscriminate destruction of exclusively civilian populations though.

    War is hell, after all. All war is hell. It always kills civilians if they are present, yet it remains legal if pursued with appropriate “care”. It takes more, then, than fighting occuring within residential areas to demonstrate the targeting of civilians.