• 1 Post
  • 868 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 28th, 2023

help-circle



  • People may prefer cheap to expensive but that does not mean they are desperate.

    Again, your conditional statement is doing a hurculean amount of lifting here. We know that healthcare is unaffordable for a large swath of our population, but are you implying that mental healthcare (which doesn’t have nearly the coverage on most plans as physical healthcare) wouldn’t be in a similar state? Because mental healthcare is out of the reach of a lot of people.

    The option isn’t just cheap or expensive therapy. No therapy is as much an option if the therapy quality was 90s level machine chat bot.

    False dichotomy, the chat bot can be better than the 90s bots but still be bad. And ‘no therapy’ isn’t an option for a lot of people who will self harm as a coping mechanism.

    Why is it exactly a problem that people have an extra avenue to better mental well being?

    Why is it a good thing that people are using a tool that will yes-and just about anything they say and lead to psychosis in patients with no accountability from the provider?




  • having the ability to do so doesn’t necessarily mean they will do so.

    No, but they have a profit motive to do so. And I’d rather assume the worst and be wrong rather than deal with another 23andMe situation in a decade. Because it will happen eventually. VC money isn’t endless, and they’re pissing away money like a pro athlete in a club.

    You can trust them if you want, but I’m not naive enough to do that myself.

    There are plenty of terrible therapists, preists, family, and friends out there.

    Preaching to the choir, I’ve dumped people from all noted categories for being shitty. I gave up on therapy about 15 years ago but my partner convinced me to go back. I looked for someone who fit my specific needs, and found someone who is rebuilding my trust in therapists

    I trust my therapist not to randomly decide to give out my info because their job relies on that. AI chat bots flat out tell you they will use what you give them for their ‘training’ purposes, which means they have access to it and can use it or sell it as they please.


  • Is it somehow better to go to an actual church or pay someone to confide in?

    Objectively yes.

    A real person isn’t a stochastic parrot yes-anding whatever stupid idea falls out of your head and is less likely to provide obsequious responses to questions asked.

    A real person is less likely to compile what you say to them and mine data from it or turn it over to authorities without a warrant.

    A real person also has the ability to actually understand what you’re saying and provide an intelligent response rather than getting back a statistical block of words that are mathematically good words to use based on the underlying model.



  • they are not wrong that for the regular person, who struggles with even the most basic IT shit, there still isn’t a full “finished” option for them,

    My dead mother, who couldn’t run windows for more than 6 months without trashing the install used mint without issue for years before she died in like 22. If my tech illiterate mother can do it, just about anyone can.

    The average user basically just needs a web browser and some office tools. If they can’t figure out how to use those in a different interface, they probably need to attend a ‘remedial computers 01’ course.

    Facebook works just as well on Linus as windows. Most people are too scared to try, not unable to use it in my experience.